Kitchen Cabinets: Drawers vs. Roll Out Trays

Kitchen cabinet drawers present homeowners with another way to store things.  Rather than a regular kitchen base cabinet with a door/drawer combination, some people prefer drawer base cabinets because they can be easier to get into.  Instead of having to open a door, then bend over and rummage around inside of the cabinet, people can just open the drawer and get at their stuff right away.

There’s some help with this, and it’s roll out trays.  Some kitchen cabinet manufacturers call them sliding shelves.  Sometimes the terms are used interchangeably, but be sure to ask if you’re contemplating either; trays are generally very shallow kitchen cabinet drawers boxes with glides, while sliding shelves are usually just a plank on rollers.

Even so, some people would rather have kitchen cabinet drawers than door and drawer cabinets with roll outs.  There’s an extra step with roll outs, and that’s the opening of the doors.  If you want to get at your stuff instantly, then kitchen cabinet drawers are for you.

Any of the kitchen cabinet manufacturers I’ve dealt with make drawer bases, but there are a couple of variations.  There’s the three drawer base, the four drawer base, and these are very common.  What I don’t see a lot of is two drawer units.  These are very deep kitchen cabinet drawers, and very handy for pot and pan storage.

In the three and four drawer bases, sometimes you can get an option for one drawer being particularly deep, sometimes they’re only offered in equal depths.  You’ll have to hunt around to see who makes which configurations exactly. 

One thing that kitchen cabinet drawers don’t do well though is look like doors.  You can have the most functional kitchen in the world, but if it doesn’t look right, it will grate on you until the next remodel.  That’s a long time.

There has to be some balance between function and appearance, so just throwing kitchen cabinet drawer bases all over the place might not be the ticket to a happy kitchen.  When I’m designing, I like having them on at least one side of the stove.  A big 30-36 inch one.  I think that with the peg board drawer organizers so many manufacturers have now, they’re a real treat to use.

Door type cabinets have advantages too though.  There are sheet and tray dividers now that you get can, and they slide out too.  This might be easier than the horizontal storage offered by kitchen cabinet drawers.  Cake pans might also be better stored in a door/drawer or full height door cabinet than a cabinet with just drawers.  It’s up to the chef in the end, whichever way better suits the style of the person cooking is the way to go.

4 Comments »

  1. Can you tell me how to balance island drawers?
    We have two, which close, but then slide back out 2-3 inches.
    Thanks,
    Bob

    Comment by Bob Daly — June 11, 2010 @ 7:27 am

  2. Do you sell a 2 drawer pot and pan cabinet 42inches wide?

    Comment by Greg Goeken — June 13, 2010 @ 1:53 am

  3. Bob, sounds like either there’s something wrong with the actual drawer mechanisms, or the cabinets aren’t level. It could also be some combination of the two. If you want to contact me directly (use the contact link) I’ll see if I can help long distance; maybe even turn it into an article to help the next person that comes along with the same problem. I’d need to know the brand and (roughly) the year of the cabinets so I can track down what’s actually in there for innards.

    Comment by Craig — June 13, 2010 @ 8:41 am

  4. I don’t sell anything here Greg, this is just an informative site. I do sell cabinets over at The Cabinet Folks though, and can look into it when I get back to the office. Bertch only makes a 36” two drawer cabinet.
    I have a Bremtown spec book (but don’t carry the line) and see that they do in fact make a 42” two drawer cabinet. Stay tuned and I’ll keep you posted.

    Comment by Craig — June 13, 2010 @ 8:45 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment



Other Construction Articles